This makes me want one of those vaguely ridic Sliding Doors/Family Man/Mr. Destiny type of stories. Maybe Harvey and Mike have dodged a few close calls at being found out, and after the third time they added another ill-advised layer by (finally - FINALLY) letting their unresolved tension result in getting together, and then the fourth time, when it seems like the might be caught for real, they choose to get out while they can, while things can go away quietly, and the relationship is part of that, pretty mutually, just to tie up another loose thread, except it’s a rom com, so there’s always that moment where they could’ve said something differently or done something else and stayed together, but they don’t.
Fast forward like 5 or 6 years, and Harvey’s on track to becoming a managing partner and hears about Mike working as a public defender or with non-profits like the Innocence Project or something, idk, idgaf, the point is he meets Don Cheadle: Secret Angel in a convenience store has his semi-magical could’ve-been-different moment and then wakes up in an alternate reality where he and Mike stayed together even if people learning that increased suspicions and Harvey was eventually suspended and Mike was kicked out on his ass and very nearly went to jail if not for some narrative miracle. Whatever, clearly I don’t know those details either, or what, exactly, they’re each doing for a living now, but probably they’re not quite making as much money. They are in love, however, and Mike Ross is adorable, and it’s weird because their relationship, whatever it was, was somehow still pretty fresh when they split up their lives, compared to the years-long situation Harvey’s plopped into in this alternate reality. (I typed “ultimate reality” at first, make of that what you will.)
Now Harvey’s in this place where he and Mike live together, and Mike gets surprised that Harvey is surprised by that, and where is his private elevator, seriously? But then, you know, obviously Mike Ross is impossible to resist and Harvey gets used to this new life, after some trial and error at trying to deny that this is his life, you know how these stories go. Eventually it stops being weird and starts feeling OK, pretty good, actually, that Mike’s around and that apparently Harvey was talking particulars with a place about styles and customization for a ring, maybe, hypothetically, and perhaps it’s too bad that he didn’t keep in touch with Mike in another life, and then it feels stranger to finally wake up in his glass apartment of emotion again, alone.
So of couse he looks up how to get in touch with Mike. It’s been six years, but for Harvey it feels like yesterday, and Mike had been a guy who’d gone back to not caring too much about suits much yesterday, but here he’s got suits and cases, and there’s a guy in prison for life right now who’s innocent, Mike knows it. It’s just catching up, just a few dinners and meetings, but Mike isn’t stupid, so he inevitably asks what Harvey wants, if something’s wrong, if someone found some kind of evidence that they — but, no, Harvey says. He heard about a case Mike was working on. Just wanted to check in. Harvey offers to help, which Mike is pretty obviously not buying, but Harvey is Harvey, and they’ve always worked well together. They spend more time, and old habits start to surface, and Harvey doesn’t quite say he missed Mike, and they sleep together, because it’s been a while and, after six years, Mike’s still a sucker for caring, and Harvey’s apparently a sucker for Mike.
Shit is complicated when you broke up to protect yourselves, though. It doesn’t make a whole lot of sense to just invite significant liability back in, but Mike and Harvey have always worked on instinct as much as smarts, and some people you can’t help. Things are okay until Mike loses a case, until those kind of moments make him wonder still, sometimes, if he shouldn’t be doing this. He’s isn’t qualified, tecnnically, and what are they doing, really? Why is Harvey around? Why now? And maybe in the middle of Mike’s mild panic for old times’ sake is when Harvey says, “I want to marry you,” which isn’t calming but does trip Mike up for a second.
It’s long enough for Harvey to add, “I don’t mean right now.”
“Then why say it?” Mike asks.
“You like when people are honest.”
Mike says, “Don’t patronize me. It’s been six years. We knew we — everything. It was a bad idea.”
“Getting caught impersonating a legitimate attorney is a bad idea,” Harvey says. “Keeping you around made sense.”
Mike does some more freaking out, but more quietly, and then he says, “No, Harvey,” and walks away, because that’s how these things go, right. It’s the second moment where things could be different, but this time Mike turns around and says, “So you’re telling me this isn’t a bad idea to you? Right now?” which stops Harvey, too, and he says, “I’m saying six years ago, I should’ve had a better one.”
And idk idk idk it’s really hard to imagine Harvey in canon now being the kind of person who wants to marry anybody, but I do feel like if he ever became someone inclined, he’d be pretty direct about those intentions, and Mike Ross will always be a mildly panicky wretch who bleeds “love me, love me” into the universe until he realizes, finally with some kind of certainty, that Harvey does.